By Michael R. Mantell, Ph.D., in El Cajon, California

Michael R. Mantell, Ph.D. (author photo)

September 11 is a date that many of us carry differently. For some, the memories remain painfully vivid: where we were when we heard the news, the images that filled our television screens, the names and faces of people who never came home.

For others, the events are increasingly part of history, remembered through stories told by parents, teachers, and grandparents. And for many of us, the anniversary brings a complicated mixture of grief, anger, fear, gratitude, and uncertainty.

 
Jewish tradition gives us a language for living with difficult memories: zachor, remember. Remembering is not simply an act of looking backward. In Jewish life, memory can be a way of shaping how we live in the present and how we imagine the future.
 
This is one reason the Mussar tradition can offer a meaningful framework for approaching September 11. Mussar invites us to pay attention to our inner lives, to the emotions, impulses, and assumptions that arise within us, and to use that awareness as an opportunity for tikkun, for growth and repair. We are not expected to eliminate difficult feelings. Instead, we can learn to meet them with greater awareness, compassion, patience, humility, and courage.
 
On September 11, that might mean noticing our grief without judging it, acknowledging anger without allowing it to harden into hatred, and recognizing fear without letting fear define our choices. It might mean practicing hakarat hatov, gratitude for the people who helped others in moments of extraordinary danger and for the ordinary blessings that can become newly visible when we remember how fragile life can be.
 
Most importantly, Mussar asks us to consider what our emotions call us to do. How can remembrance deepen our commitment to chesed? [kindness]. How can grief make us more attentive to the suffering of others? How can we honor those who died by choosing, in whatever small ways are available to us, to create more kindness, connection, and hope?
There is no single Jewish way to experience September 11. Some will pray. Some will attend a communal gathering. Some will read names or stories. Some will prefer quiet reflection. Some may find the anniversary difficult enough that they need to step away from the news and give themselves space. All of these can be legitimate ways of remembering.
 
What follows is a brief Mussar practice for September 11, an invitation to pause, notice what is present within us, turn toward a middah that can help guide us, and conclude with a small act of chesed.
 
We cannot change what happened. But we can choose what kind of people we will be as we remember.
 

From a Jewish Mussar perspective, September 11 can be approached not by trying to eliminate painful emotions, but by meeting them consciously and using them as an opportunity for avodah (inner work). A Mussar approach might look like this:

Notice what arises. 

Sadness, anger, fear, grief, helplessness, even numbness are not failures. Practice hakarat ha-emet—recognizing honestly what is happening within you—without immediately judging it.

Practice compassion (rachamim). Extend gentleness toward yourself and toward the people whose lives were shattered. You don’t have to force yourself to “move on.” Compassion can include simply saying: This is painful, and I am allowed to feel it.

Work with anger (ka’as). Mussar doesn’t require pretending that anger isn’t there. Instead, notice what anger wants to do. Give it a pause before turning it into hatred or dehumanization. Ask: What response to this tragedy reflects the person I want to become?

Cultivate gratitude (hakarat hatov). This isn’t gratitude for the tragedy. It’s gratitude for the people, relationships, acts of courage, and ordinary blessings that become especially visible when remembering loss.

Practice patience (savlanut). Anniversaries can bring emotions back unexpectedly. Mussar’s emphasis on patience can mean allowing yourself to have a difficult day without demanding that you feel differently.

Turn memory into action. One particularly Jewish response to loss is zachor—remember. You might dedicate the day to a small act of chesed (loving-kindness), charity, visiting someone lonely, helping someone in need, or strengthening a relationship. The question becomes: How can remembering the dead deepen the way I live?

End with teshuvah. In Mussar, painful awareness can become an invitation to return—to one’s values, Hashem, community, and better self. You might ask: What kind of person do I want to be because I remember? What is one thing I can repair or strengthen?

A simple Mussar practice for September 11 could be:

I will not push this feeling away.

I will not let it rule me.

I will listen to what it teaches me.

May memory lead me toward compassion, courage, and kindness.

May the lives lost call me to live my own life more faithfully.

And if the day brings particularly intense emotions, there’s no Mussar requirement to sit with them indefinitely. Seeking another person’s presence, taking a walk, praying, turning off the news, or giving yourself permission to step away from anniversary coverage can itself be wise middah work.

 And here is a gentle 10–15 minute, psychologically-anchored, Mussar practice for September 11, designed to help hold grief without becoming overwhelmed by it.

A 10–15 minute September 11 Mussar practice

1. Arrive — 1 minute

Sit somewhere quiet. Put both feet on the floor and take three slow breaths.

Say quietly:

Hineni — here I am.

I don’t have to solve what happened.

I don’t have to make myself feel a certain way.

I am here to remember, to feel, and to choose how I will respond.

Let whatever emotion is present be there.

2. Choose one middah — 2 minutes

Choose the quality you most need today:

Rachamim — compassion: Can I be gentle with myself and others?

Savlanut — patience: Can I allow difficult feelings without demanding that they disappear?

Anavah — humility: Can I accept that some things are beyond my control?

Chesed — loving-kindness: How can I bring a little more goodness into someone else’s life?

Ometz — courage: What would it mean to remain open-hearted despite painful memories?

Hakarat hatov — gratitude: What blessing in my life do I not want to take for granted?

Don’t try to perfect the middah. Just notice where you are with it.

3. Read a Psalm — 2–3 minutes

A particularly fitting choice is Psalm 23 (Tehillim 23), especially if you need a sense of being accompanied through frightening territory.

You might focus on:

Gam ki eilech b’gei tzalmavet, lo ira ra…

“Even though I walk through the valley of deepest darkness, I will not be afraid…”

You don’t have to interpret the verse. Let the words accompany you.

If Psalm 23 doesn’t feel right, Psalm 121 can be a beautiful alternative.

4. Let the emotion speak — 3 minutes

Ask yourself:

What am I feeling today?

Then ask:

Where do I feel it in my body?

What is this feeling asking me to acknowledge?

Is there grief underneath my anger? Fear underneath my need for control?

What would compassion toward myself look like right now?

Try not to argue with your answers.

Mussar is often less about getting rid of a feeling than about learning what the feeling reveals about the soul.

5. Transform memory into one act — 2 minutes

Ask:

If I want the memory of September 11 to make me a more loving person rather than a more fearful person, what is one small thing I can do today?

Keep it concrete.

Perhaps:

Call someone you’ve been meaning to call.

Give tzedakah.

Help a stranger.

Forgive a small grievance.

Sit with someone who is lonely.

Tell someone you love them.

Do an act of kindness anonymously.

Then say:

Zikaron l’bracha — may memory become a blessing.

May remembering those who died deepen the way I live.

6. Close — 1–2 minutes

Put your hand over your heart if that feels comfortable.

Say:

Ribbono Shel Olam, Master of the Universe,

Hold in Your compassion all those whose lives were lost and all those whose lives were forever changed.

Help me remember without being consumed by fear.

Help me grieve without losing hope.

Help me feel anger without becoming cruel.

Help me meet suffering with compassion.

Help me use the life I have been given for chesed, courage, and peace.

May the memory of those who died be a blessing.

Yehi zichram baruch.

And may I honor their memory through the way I live today.

Take one final slow breath.

Then stop. You don’t need to produce a profound insight. In Mussar, showing up honestly is already part of the work.

If you find that September 11 brings up trauma-level fear, panic, or intrusive memories, it’s also completely consistent with Jewish wisdom to seek the support of a trusted rabbi, loved one, or mental-health professional. You don’t have to carry it alone.

*
Michael R. Mantell, Ph.D., is a freelance writer based in El Cajon, California.