By Cailin Acosta in La Mesa, California
In the aftermath of World War II, a train carries children away from the poverty of southern Italy toward the possibility of a better life. For one young boy, the journey brings opportunity, but it also forces him to confront difficult questions about family, love and where he belongs.
The Children’s Train (Il treno dei bambini), a 2024 Italian historical drama directed by Cristina Comencini, tells the story of Amerigo, a young boy whose impoverished mother, Antonietta, makes the painful decision to send him from Naples to live with a family in northern Italy. Based on Viola Ardone’s 2019 novel, the film draws inspiration from the real-life Treni della Felicità, or “Happiness Trains,” which transported thousands of children from impoverished southern Italian communities to families in the north between 1945 and 1952.
The film opens a window into a country struggling to recover from war. In Naples, hunger and hardship shape everyday life. Antonietta, a single mother with limited resources, recognizes that she cannot provide Amerigo with everything he needs. Sending him away may offer opportunities she cannot provide, but the decision comes at a tremendous emotional cost.
Amerigo arrives in northern Italy unsure of what awaits him. His new caretaker, Derna, welcomes him into a household where he experiences greater comfort, education and affection. He discovers new interests, including music, and begins to imagine a future beyond the limitations of his childhood circumstances.
Yet the contrast between his two homes creates its own difficulties. Amerigo must navigate unfamiliar surroundings while remaining emotionally connected to the mother he left behind. What initially appears to be a straightforward opportunity for a better life becomes a complicated story about loyalty, identity and the meaning of home.
Christian Cervone brings vulnerability to the role of young Amerigo, while Serena Rossi portrays Antonietta as a mother whose harshness is inseparable from the struggle to survive. Barbara Ronchi gives Derna warmth and complexity, making her more than simply a generous stranger offering a child a second chance.
One of the film’s strengths is its refusal to portray motherhood in simple terms. Antonietta’s choices hurt her son, yet Amerigo cannot fully understand the circumstances behind them. As he discovers a world of possibilities that once seemed beyond reach, the distance between mother and son grows. The film asks viewers to consider whether a parent’s sacrifice can be an expression of love even when a child experiences it as rejection.
Although the story is not specifically Jewish, its themes of displacement, family separation and rebuilding lives after war may resonate with Jewish audiences. The Holocaust shattered families and left many Jewish children without parents, homes or familiar communities. The circumstances depicted in this film are different, but its questions about belonging, the responsibilities adults have toward children, and the lasting consequences of war invite reflection.
The Happiness Trains also offer an example of communities responding to the needs of vulnerable children. By opening their homes to children from impoverished families, ordinary Italians helped provide food, education and stability during a difficult period. Their actions demonstrate how people beyond a child’s immediate family can play a meaningful role in shaping that child’s future.
At times, the film’s episodic storytelling moves quickly through events that might have benefited from greater development. Nevertheless, the performances and the emotional conflict at its center keep the story engaging.
As Amerigo grows older, he must reconsider his childhood and the decisions that shaped his life. The later scenes bring the complicated relationship between mother and son into sharper focus, reminding viewers that people do not always express love in ways others can recognize at the time.
The Children’s Train is ultimately a moving historical drama about the difference between providing for a child and understanding what that child needs emotionally. Its central message is that love, sacrifice and belonging are rarely simple. Sometimes, understanding a parent’s decisions takes a lifetime.
The Children’s Train (2024), directed by Cristina Comencini, is an Italian-language historical drama based on Viola Ardone’s novel. The film runs approximately 105 minutes and is available on Netflix.
*
Cailin Acosta is the assistant editor of the San Diego Jewish World.