By Rabbi Dr. Michael Leo Samuel in Chula Vista, California

An oft-told joke pictures an Israeli prime minister and an Arab leader standing side by side at the Western Wall in Jerusalem. Knowing that this is the place where Jews pour out their hearts to God, the Arab leader bows his head and prays, “May God grant us wisdom to resolve our bitter dispute.”
“Amen,” replies the prime minister.
The Arab leader continues, “May our peoples discover the paths to reconciliation.”
“Amen,” says the prime minister.
“May a true and lasting peace reign across the Middle East.”
“Amen.”
Encouraged, the Arab leader offers one final prayer: “And may Israel dismantle all its settlements and withdraw from every inch of the West Bank.”
The prime minister glances at him and says, “Now you’re just talking to the wall.”
It is a great line—precisely because we know that for Jews, talking to that wall is anything but an exercise in futility. Yet it raises a deeper question: what is it about stone that gives human beings a sense of the sacred?
Looked at with cold, rational eyes, the Western Wall is simply a stack of massive limestone blocks—a retaining wall built by King Herod to support the plaza of Mount Moriah, where the Temple once stood. It is not the sanctuary itself; it is an outer wall. Yet for centuries, Jews have crossed oceans and risked their lives simply to press their foreheads against its weathered crevices and whisper a prayer.
Jews are hardly alone in their devotion to sacred stone. Consider Scotland’s historic Stone of Scone—a 458-pound block of rough-hewn sandstone on which Scottish monarchs were crowned beginning in the ninth century. Seized in 1296 by King Edward I of England and placed beneath the coronation throne in Westminster Abbey, it was not returned to Scotland until 1996—seven hundred years later. Remarkably, Scottish legend claims that this very block is the stone on which the patriarch Jacob rested his head when he dreamed of a ladder reaching to heaven in Parashat Vayetze.
Across the world, people anchor memory in rock. Americans make pilgrimages to Plymouth Rock, the storied landing place of the Pilgrims. Visitors to Ireland lean backward to kiss the Blarney Stone in hopes of acquiring the gift of eloquence. Muslims turn five times daily toward the Kaaba in Mecca, kissing or gesturing toward the sacred Black Stone set into its eastern corner. And at the very heart of Jerusalem’s Temple Mount, beneath the Dome of the Rock, lies the Foundation Stone—the pinnacle of Mount Moriah, where tradition tells us Abraham bound Isaac upon the altar.
In the Hebrew Bible, stone is the primary medium of memory. Whenever a moment mattered too much to be trusted to fragile human recollection, our ancestors set up a stone. Jacob and Laban piled stones on Mount Gilead to seal their covenant (Genesis 31:46). Joshua erected twelve stones taken from the riverbed at Gilgal so future generations would remember Israel’s miraculous crossing of the Jordan (Joshua 4:5–7). Later, the tribes west of the Jordan built an altar of witness to affirm their bond with their kin across the river (Joshua 22:10).
Out of this lived experience, stone became one of Scripture’s richest metaphors for God Himself: Tzur Yisrael—the Rock of Israel—echoing David’s song, “The Lord is my rock, my fortress, and my deliverer” (II Samuel 22:2). And in Psalm 118:22, stone becomes a symbol of redemption and unexpected grace: “The stone that the builders rejected has become the chief cornerstone.”
Why does stone speak so powerfully to the human soul? Because everything else in life is fleeting. Emotions shift, generations pass, and empires rise and fall—but stone endures. When Jacob lay down in the dark in Parsha Vayetze, he had no home, no altar, and no certainty about tomorrow. All he had was a hard stone beneath his head. Yet on that bare rock, heaven opened, angels ascended and descended, and an ordinary patch of earth became Beit El—the House of God.
Rocks speak because we pour our hopes, our griefs, and our prayers into them until they become witnesses to the divine. May the memory of Jacob’s pillow—where earth and heaven once met in peace—inspire both Israelis and Arabs to bring that same sense of the sacred to the negotiating table, turning walls that divide us into cornerstones of a lasting peace.
*
Rabbi Dr. Michael Leo Samuel is the spiritual leader of Temple Beth Shalom in Chula Vista, California.