By Shor M. Masori in Chula Vista, California

David Deutsch was responsible for other people’s teenagers on the Hod Hasharon campus north of Tel Aviv during the war. At Alexander Muss High School in Israel, where students from abroad spend a semester studying Jewish history in the places it happened, he expected parents to bring them home. The teenagers wanted to stay. His own child came to campus, too. “It’s not that things were easy. Not for me. My kid was with me also on campus because he didn’t want to stay home alone.”
In a student video he played, two girls who had been sick described missing the others’ party. Deutsch had been there when an argument broke out over who got the better bed in the shelter. As their voices rose, Deutsch, the deputy head for student experience, wanted to step in, but was quickly shooed off. “We got this,” one said. They settled it and shook hands.
At Jewish National Fund-USA’s conference in Chula Vista, Deutsch described what he wanted his students to take home from Muss. “I think you are Zionism,” he said. How the students understood that word would help decide what it meant to their generation. Three of the students who had stayed through the war were at the conference. Deutsch said he was moved to see them.
In line at Burekas Box, the kosher food stand, I met Danielle Fern and Valeria Garber. Both had spent a semester at Muss. Fern said her mother suggested the school at a time when “a part of me wasn’t fully whole yet.” I asked if she’d found that piece. She had. She felt more mature, more independent and more able to be selfless.
Garber had wanted to go since eighth grade. After the October 7 attack, she couldn’t imagine spending five months in Israel without family there. A friend who had gone told her, “If you go, you won’t regret it. If you don’t go, you’ll regret it.” She lay awake that night. “It was like 2 in the morning. I opened my computer and I applied. And I think it’s the best decision I made.”
They spent January through May with sophomores and juniors from the United States, Canada, and Mexico. The students described learning Jewish history in class one day and visiting the site where it happened the next. In their modern topics class, a teacher read the news with them and explained why people’s views were shifting. Garber said that knowing the news and having lived in Israel during the war gave her “more tools to have the harder conversations that I wouldn’t want to have before.”
At the panel “From Likes to Leadership,” social media creators took a question from a high school student from Ohio. In Israel, the student had grown more confident about being Jewish. Back home, “I felt like I was going backwards again.” How could the student speak up without driving friends away?
Ben Carasso, one of the panelists, was eleven. He had posted his first video about October 7 when he was eight. He wanted grown-ups to give Jewish children a chance to say what they had seen. While Ben spoke, I saw fellow panelist Noa Barazani perfectly encapsulate audience sentiment towards Ben as she mouthed “I love him” in astonishment to a friend. Barazani founded Olim in TLV, where she makes videos about moving to Israel, and HookedIRL, a dating app that lets people at the same event see who else is single.
Ben suggested showing friends what the student had enjoyed in Israel, the culture and the friendships. Logan Levkoff, the moderator, reminded the student, “There’s nothing like firsthand experience.”
A mother in the audience had asked about teenagers in her daughter’s program who hesitated to post. Eli Wininger, one of the panelists, suggested starting with something they already made. Someone who posted about food or comedy could let viewers see a little of their own Jewish life there.
In France, Philippe Lévy gives teenagers a chance to practice what they want to say. In theater workshops at KKL France, the French arm of the Jewish National Fund, they rehearse how to make an argument. “On stage, I learned that how you stand changes what you can say,” the former teacher told us.
Author Dara Horn, founder of The Tell Institute, described giving students an accusation against Jews to take apart. Who circulated it? What value did the accusers say they were defending? What were Jews being blamed for? One case could be carried by a printing press, another by radio. What would a student want to know about the person putting the same accusation on their phone?
Gadi Ezra, an Israeli educator helping to plan the World Zionist Village in Be’er Sheva, wants students to help answer a question he considers open. “Contemporary Zionism isn’t defined.” Theodor Herzl’s Congress and David Ben-Gurion’s founding generation had different work to do. What should a young person do for a state that already exists? Ezra envisions a high school and a storytelling academy where a student might write a script or defend a position in debate.
Ezra asked a man in the audience where he was from. New Jersey. And where was his family from? Poland and Russia. Ezra’s own family came from Iraq and Yemen. Yet here the two of them were in San Diego County talking about a country half a world away. “We are part of the same story,” Ezra said.
In line at the food stand, I had put a version of Ezra’s question to Fern and Garber. I’d heard plenty of adults worry about the future of Zionism. Where did the two of them think it was going? Fern wanted the people she cared about to know what she had lived through. “I feel like educating people is great, but not everyone will listen to you,” she said. She could choose who she spent her time with. She wanted friends who understood her and would stand by her.
Garber had been thinking about children younger than herself. “Our job is to, like, help and teach the new generation,” she said. She thought the time to reach them was before they got to college with their minds made up.
When I gave the students one more chance to speak before they ordered, the advice that had once kept Garber up all night was going in the other direction. “You should do Muss,” one said. The other added, “Everyone, if you have the opportunity, do Muss. If you don’t, look into it.”
Students in grades 10–12 can fill out the inquiry form on the Muss admissions page. The school emails the next steps.
*
Shor M. Masori is a San Diego-based freelance writer.