
Have you ever considered what it feels like to be a Jewish kid in December? Everywhere you turn, Christmas! There’s How the Grinch Stole Christmas, approximately 400 versions of A Christmas Carol, and enough productions of The Nutcracker to keep every ballet student in North America dancing through January. Don’t get me wrong, I love these shows. But wouldn’t it be nice to have just one big holiday production about our own holiday?
It’s the December dilemma North American Jews have lived with for generations, and frankly, I thought it was unsolvable. Apparently, when a neuroscientist marries a rabbi/cantor and they have two children, solving the impossible becomes a family activity. Rather than complain about the absence of a Hanukkah musical, the Gimbels wrote one. Music, lyrics, script, the whole thing.
Next weekend, JCompany opens ei8ht, an original Hanukkah musical featuring nine songs composed by 13-year-old Ari Gimbel, who helped create the show with his younger sister Maya, their mother Sarah Israel Gimbel, and Becky Cherlin Baird. Sarah also serves on our SDCJC Board and is an extraordinary JCompany volunteer.
Our JCompany Artistic Director, Erin Petersen, recognized an opportunity to bring JCompany back to its roots, where young people are not simply performers but writers, composers, choreographers, and creators. And who better to direct this production than Becky, who founded JCompany in 1993 and has returned to bring this next generation’s work to life?
I love this because it speaks directly to why the San Diego Center for Jewish Culture exists. We are not simply here to present Jewish culture. We are here to cultivate it, challenge it, create it, and ensure the next generation has the knowledge and confidence to make it their own.
What strikes me about the Gimbels’ response to the December dilemma is that they didn’t ask how to make Hanukkah look more like Christmas. They asked how to create something wonderful that was unmistakably Jewish. And that instinct, to meet the challenge of being different with imagination rather than surrendering what makes us different, is hardly new to Jewish life.
In fact, we have a Hanukkah tradition that tells almost exactly that story.
According to a beloved tradition, when Torah study was forbidden under Greek rule, Jewish children continued learning in secret. When soldiers approached, they hid their books and pulled out spinning tops, pretending they were playing. Whether or not it happened exactly this way, the lesson has stayed with us. Even a children’s game could become an act of Jewish creativity and resilience.
And what do the letters on the dreidel remind us? Nes Gadol Haya Sham. A great miracle happened there.
We usually think about the miracle of Hanukkah as the oil lasting eight days. But I wonder if there is another miracle worth considering. That after thousands of years, despite enormous pressure to assimilate, persecution, displacement, and change, we are still here, still telling our stories, and still finding new ways to express what makes us Jewish.
That kind of survival has required more than resilience. It has required extraordinary creativity.
Which brings me back to the Gimbels. Perhaps we have a new Hanukkah miracle to celebrate this year. After generations of Jewish children wondering why there wasn’t a big holiday musical about their own traditions, one family decided to create one. And a community of young artists and dedicated adults came together to bring it to life.
The miracle isn’t simply that we have a Hanukkah musical. It’s that the next generation is creating Jewish culture rather than just inheriting it. I know that there is nothing that makes grandparents Sonia and Andy z”l Israel and Joanne and Ken Gimbel more proud.
And that is precisely what we hope to make possible every day at the San Diego Center for Jewish Culture.
I hope you will join us and bring Jewish friends and friends of other faiths and no faith to celebrate these remarkable young artists.
You can enjoy ei8ht as part of our Hanukkah Happening experience on Sunday, December 6, with festivities beginning at 10:00 a.m. and the musical at 1:00 p.m. Or join us for one of the other performances on November 28, 29, 30, or December 6.
Purchase tickets for ei8ht or the Hanukkah Happening and musical experience
Happy Thanksgiving and Shavua Tov,
