By Alex Gordon in Haifa, Israel Alex Gordon, Ph.D. (Author’s Photo)
When red and green paint are mixed, a brownish shade can result, depending on the proportions and brightness of the pigments. The preferred color of German Nazism is brown. This color became the main official and symbolic colorof the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (NSDAP). Members of the party’s paramilitary formations wore brown shirts, which led to them being popularly called “Brownshirts“. The term “brown plague” has become a common expression to denote Nazism. The party headquarters in Munich was officially referred to as the “Brown House.” In the “red–green alliance” (an alliance of left–wing forces and Islamist movements), a distinct brownish tinge is evident, leading to antisemitism of Nazi caliber.
The most famous and successful example of a Marxist (“Red”)–Islamist clergy (“Green”) alliance aimed at achieving a short–term goal was Iran during the 1979 Islamic Revolution. Leftist radicals (for example, the Organization of the Iranian People’s Mojahideen or the Toode Party) joined with Islamists around the figure of Ayatollah Khomeini to overthrow the pro–Western Shah regime. They unitedbased on anti–imperialism, anti–capitalism, and the fight against monarchy. Immediately after the revolution’s victory and the consolidation of the theocratic regime, the Islamists eliminated their leftist allies, subjecting them to repression or driving them outof the country.
In several European countries, the “red–green alliance” is actively operating at the level of parliamentary opposition, electoral platforms, and street politics. The main points of contact here is the defense of migrants’ rights, anti–racism, anti–colonial rhetoric, andsupportfor Palestinian Arabs in the Middle East conflict. Jean–Luc Mélenchon’s left movement, France Unbowed (La France insoumise), successfully mobilizes the votes of Muslims in the suburbs, turning a blind eye to religious conservatismtoadvance an anti–system agenda.
Although traditional leftists promote equality and Islam–centered movements rely on religious dogma, they have found common ground in anti–colonialism, anti–Americanism, and antisemitism. The left often radicalizes its critique of Israel’s state policy. Within the red–green alliance, the right of Israel to exist is entirely denied, and the Jewish state is portrayed as the “main evil” on the world stage.This blurs the line between criticism of the government and hatred of the Jewish people. Modern leftist ideology divides the world into white oppressors and colored oppressed. In this framework, Israelis (and Jews in general) are classified as “white colonizers” and a “privileged class,” while Palestinians are seen as defenseless victims.
This deprives Jews of the status of a historically persecuted group and justifies violence against them as “acts of resistance.” The red–green coalition has legitimized antisemitism. The French writer and philosopher Pascal Bruckner, author of the book The Tyranny of Guilt: An Essay on Western Masochism wrote that European leftists are blinded by a sense of historical guilt over colonialism. Because of this, they divide the world into simplified categories: “white oppressor” (the West) and “innately innocent oppressed” (the third world / Muslims). Within this logic, any actions of the “oppressed” (including terrorism andreligiousfundamentalism)areromanticizedandjustifiedbytheleft.
For radical Islamists, the West is the enemy of faith. For the ultra–left, it is a bastion of capitalism and imperialism. Israel is perceived by both currents as the “outpost” of American influence in the Middle East. The struggle against it becomes a sacred goal forbothsides.
The “green” part of the coalition (which includes radical migrants from Muslim countries) brings with it entrenched religious and geopolitical antisemitism. Left–wing parties, in their struggle for the votes of Muslim voters, turn a blind eye to these manifestations of hatred, calling them “protests against occupation” and thereby legitimizing aggression. In the rhetoric of the alliance, updated old myths reminiscent ofThe Protocols of the Elders of Zionoften resurface about the “omnipotent Jewish lobby” that secretly controls the politics of the USA and Europe, and about the “financialelite”profitingfromwars.
The left sees Islamists as an oppressed minority, victims of Western capitalism, colonialism, and globalization. Islamists use democracy, which they do not recognize for themselves, but recognize for others. They use media support and the human rights rhetoric of the left to legitimize their presence in the legal framework of Western states.
Apparently, antisemitism provides left–wing radicals with “absolution”: they have abandoned their own values, their struggle for women’s and minority rights, by allying with forces of religious reaction. Despite the significant difference in values, there areregular jointappearances by leftist and pro–Islamist activists at anti–war and pro–Palestinianevents.
French sociologist and political scientist Pierre–André Taguieff popularized the term “islamo–leftism” (islamo–gauchisme), describing it as the willingness of some leftists to turn a blind eye to fundamentalism and the religious reaction of Islamists in the common struggle against “Western imperialism” and capitalism. The left has traditionally advocated for women’s emancipation, freedom of expression, and LGBTQ rights. The ideology of radical Islamism demands strict adherence to religious norms (Sharia), the restriction of women’s rights, and the persecution of minorities. Turning a blind eye to this for the sake of “joint struggle,” the left betrays the very groups they pride themselves on protecting.
The left movement has historically stood forthe positions of a secular state and criticism of clericalism. An alliance with fundamentalist religious structures turns the left into silent allies of a religious dictatorship. Under the guise of “anti–colonial struggle” and support for Palestinian resistance (including organizations like Hamas), the left thus justifies terrorism, murder, and the taking of hostages of peaceful citizens, which contradicts humanist ethics. The alliance with Islamists requires leftist radicals to apply double standards: while condemning any manifestationsofconservatism,nationalism,orreligiouspressure at home (for example, in Christian or secular environments), they show leniency or complete justification for much harsher forms of religious obscurantism and violence ifit comes from Islamist circles.
Pierre–André Taguieff criticizes the left for idealizing Muslim minorities in their search for a “new proletariat” (instead of the vanished working class), turning a blind eye to religious extremism and antisemitism. According to Taguieff, this has led to the replacementofclassstrugglewithracialandculturalidentity.
According to the French philosopher, writer, and politician of Jewish descent Bernard– Henri Lévy, radical leftists use Islamists to dismantle democratic institutions, not realizing that if successful, the totalitarian religious model will consume them as well. He consistently condemns the “red–green” alliance, calling it the capitulation of intellectuals to a new type of totalitarianism. Levy emphasizes that modern radical leftists use the suffering of Palestinians not for the sake of peace, but as a tool for dismantling Western democracy, uniting with reactionary religious fanatics for this purpose.
The red–green antisemitic alliance is making its brown fascist march across Europe, pushing Jews out of the Old World. It is also pushing Europe out of Western civilization.
* Alex Gordon is professor emeritus of physics at the University of Haifa and at Oranim, the Academic College of Education, and the author of 12 books.
1 thought on “The red-green antisemitism”
Steve Futterman
Brilliant. Thank you professor for telling the truth. The question remains, why do so many American Jews who created the left that was once aligned with western and classical liberal values now support the vile, illiberal, anti west, antisemitic, homophonic, misogynistic ideology of the red-green alliance. Many voted for candidates that believe that the rape and mutilation of Jewish woman maybe was a bit unfortunate but hey they had it coming to them. The moral confusion is dangerously tragic.
Brilliant. Thank you professor for telling the truth. The question remains, why do so many American Jews who created the left that was once aligned with western and classical liberal values now support the vile, illiberal, anti west, antisemitic, homophonic, misogynistic ideology of the red-green alliance. Many voted for candidates that believe that the rape and mutilation of Jewish woman maybe was a bit unfortunate but hey they had it coming to them. The moral confusion is dangerously tragic.